Black and white photo of Comanche Indians sitting and standing next to bison enclosure. Wichita Mountains are in the background.

How the American Bison Became Our National Mammal

The WCS Archives presents a new display of collection materials each month at Wildlife Conservation Society offices. We invite those who are not able to view the case in person to explore this digital version.

The story of the restoration of bison to the American West is one that is well known in both conservation and zoo circles. During the nineteenth century, the mass slaughter of bison brought the species to the brink of extinction.

A diverse, behind-the-scenes effort by hundreds of people across the country brought bison back from the brink. This effort materialized through the formation of networks and affiliations, fundraising, legislation, tremendous physical labor, and individual champions of wildlife.

The project of saving the species from extinction holds some of conservation’s greatest success stories.

Prefatory note on page from "The Extermination of the American Bison" by William T. Hornday.
In 1889, future Bronx Zoo Director William Hornaday published a stark portrait of the species’ destruction. Titled The Extermination of the American Bison, Hornaday’s study found that the American bison population had fallen as low as 1,000. The number continued to decline for several more years.
Black & white photo of American Bison Society members pose on staircase at Bronx Zoo's Rocking Stone Restaurant.
American Bison Society at Bronx Zoo’s Rocking Stone Restaurant.
Top: Frederick H. Kennard. Middle, L-R: Harry V. Radford, Charles H. Stonebridge.
Center front: William Hornaday. Far right: Ernest Harold Baynes. Far left: Edward Cave.

Field naturalist J. Alden Loring surveyed the Wichita Forest Reserve in southwestern Oklahoma on behalf of the New York Zoological Society in 1905. There he interviewed plainsmen and Comanche Indians—for whom, like many Native Americans, bison were of vital physical and cultural importance—and asked about the prospect of the government officially establishing a bison range. Quannah Parker, Comanche Chief, reportedly told Loring, “Tell the President that the buffalo is my old friend, and it would make my heart glad to see a herd once more roaming about [the reserve.]”

Other tribes had made efforts to save the endangered species in the 1800s. At the Flathead reservation in Montana, a man from the Ql̓ispé tribe went east of the reservation to bring a few calves over the Rocky Mountains and home to Flathead. Two ranchers there later bought the increasing herd, which would become the largest in the nation in the early 1900s. Some of that herd would be sold and breed other herds.

Front page of pamphlet showing black and white illustration of one bison.
First page of "An Appeal for the Buffalo" pamphlet text.
Excerpts from “An Appeal for Buffalo.” The pamphlet introduced the American Bison Society, their cause, and the plan to the United States government, circa 1907.
  • Black and white photo of men standing alongside a bison in a crate mounted to a wagon at the Bronx Zoo.
  • Black and white photo of men standing alongside railroad freight cars outfitted for horses. Railroad tracks in foreground.
  • Black and white photo of horse-drawn wagons crossing Oklahoma plains. Wichita Mountains in background.
  • Black and white photo of Comanche Indians sitting and standing next to bison enclosure. Wichita Mountains are in the background.
Bison from the Bronx Zoo were part of a “nucleus herd” transported to the Wichita Forest and Game Preserve (now known as the Wichita Mountains Wildlife Reserve), Oklahoma, October 1907.
Reproduction of Oct. 1, 1907 letter written by Hornaday on American Bison Society letterhead. Marginalia by Davenport Zoological Society at lower edge.
A census survey sent by Hornaday, with responses from the Davenport Zoological Park. The greater preservation effort also took the form of intense, regular census research to understand the population status of the American bison. In 1907, for instance, Hornaday surveyed dozens of zoo, park, and preserve administrators; ranchers; and animal dealers to analyze the size of the bison population.

The ABS’s success was additionally due to the support not only of President Roosevelt but also of dozens of legislators. In 1908, several members of Congress secured the passage of the Bison Range Act, under which the U.S. government provided lands in Montana for a national bison herd. Some of that herd had grown from the bison nurtured at the Flathead Reservation from the 1880s to early 1900s.

Reproduction of American Bison Society request for monetary subscriptions toward the Montana National Bison Herd [flyer] showing black and white photo of one bison and map of range.
Montana National Bison Herd subscription flyer, 1908.

To drum up support for the Bison Range Act, Hornaday pressed 150 newspapers to write articles on the campaign. With a range secured, the ABS turned to the American people for their assistance in raising the $10,000 (over $376,000 today) required to purchase animals that would serve as the breeding nucleus for the herd. As a flyer promoting the subscription fund noted, “Any American can give a dollar; some can give more.” Although many Americans did give more, it was the hundreds of small donations of $5 or less that allowed the ABS to exceed their fundraising goal by more than $500.

Reproduction of certificate of acknowledgement showing black and white photo of one bison.
Certificate of acknowledgment for a personal contribution to the ABS for the Montana Herd, 1908.

Remarkably, within just ten years, the ABS accomplished its goal by establishing several small herds — sometimes with animals from the Bronx Zoo — in widely separated preserves across the country. By 1934, an ABS census estimated that the population of bison in the U.S. had grown to roughly 4,400.

This year, we celebrated the 10th anniversary of President Obama signing the historic National Bison Legacy Act signed into law. We laud the work that has gone into its passage, and we also remember the efforts of generations  before us that have ensured that bison continue to thrive in this country today.

Color photograph of John Calvelli speaking at lectern, as Ervin Carlson and Jason Baldes listen at right. A tall banner for American Bison is in the background.
WCS Executive Vice President of Public Affairs John Calvelli (left), Intertribal Buffalo Council President Ervin Carlson and Vice President Jason Baldes at the Bison National Mammal Commemorative Reception, Washington, D.C., June 23, 2016. Photo: Julie Larsen Maher © WCS.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.